Even now, when I see you I start to re-live you
Don't know how I could ever begin to forgive you,
I never thought about it,
I learned to live without it
But nothin' seemed to feel the same
If I should try again — and you should lie again
Don't know if I could stand the pain
Do I dare,
Let you in, once again and surrender
Should I care,
Should I trust, when my heart still remembers
How you lied, how I cried, and now you say you wanna make it right
So I ask won't you hear my prayer
Do I love, do I trust — do I dare
Tell me why,
Did you play such a game, last September
Pretty lies — were you real, were you just a pretender
But now you're back again,
Sayin' that that was then
And how you're gonna change your ways
I don't know what to do
'Cause I'm still feelin' you
But will the story end the same
Do I dare,
Let you in, once again and surrender
Should I care,
Should I trust, when my heart still remembers
How you lied, how I cried, and now you say you wanna make it right
So I ask won't you hear my prayer
Do I love, do I trust — do I dare
I never thought about it,
I learned to live without it
But now sometimes it feels just like I'm gonna die without it
I don't know what to do
'cause I'm still feelin' you
And I'm still afraid, that you could break
my heart in two
Don't know if I could stand the pain
Will the story end the same
Do I dare,
Let you in, once again and surrender
Should I care,
Should I trust, when my heart still remembers
How you lied, how I cried, and now you say you wanna make it right
So I ask won't you hear my prayer
Do I love, do I trust — do I dare